Can Mammoth Blood Enable Cloning?
The above link will bring you to National Geographic's article on how a new female mammoth carcass discovery could potentially lead to a modern-day cloning of the extinct species. Cloning extinct species is an absolutely fascinating concept to me; I am amazed and perplexed at the idea that it is even possible to resurrect animals which otherwise may never have been seen again. While I am completely in favor of saving species from extinction, the idea of 'de-extinction' really worries me.
According to the article, 'various scientific groups are aiming to recreate species such as the woolly mammoth, passenger pigeon, and mouth-brooding frog'. Aside from the mystical Frankenstein-esque connotation these attempts at recreation bring to mind, what frightens me is that I see cloning as a potential excuse to skip prevention of extinction in the first place. While I understand that cloning is often considered a scientific backup plan just in case a species is obliterated from the environment, it's a cushion that could lead to complacency in terms of protecting species abuse and habitat loss. Also, the article mentions that complications often result in the cloning process, as 'birth defects... cause clones to have relatively short lives after birth. A recently cloned Pyrenean ibex—a horned, hoofed mammal that went extinct in 2000—died only a few minutes after it was born'.
The ethics of the cloning process are quite questionable. So-called 'species revival' may not be much of a revival at all; even if we did clone a woolly mammoth, there is no guarantee that it would display the same characteristic actions or habits, 'given the complicated influences of development and environment' that determine what an organism is.
In short, I agree with Jacquelyn Gill, a paleoecology postdoctorate at Brown University, when she says, 'It's irresponsible to put limited conservation dollars into bringing an Ice Age species into a warming world where dozens of elephants have been slaughtered just this year for their ivory'.
